After a long night of dancing to house music, a typical person would be en route home to wind down for the night, preparing for what the next day will bring. But for New York City’s young and ambitious, the night has just begun, and the only right answer after an intoxicating night of hot sweat, incessant stomping to a four-on-the-floor beat, and chapped lips is—frozen yogurt?
Frozen yogurt is experiencing its third wave of popularity, following earlier reception in the 2000s. But its resurgence isn’t simply the result of people craving a quick and easy sweet treat. Instead, it reflects the power of social media influence and the enduring role of diet culture in shaping our food choices and habits.
It was a 40 minute train ride from Queens back into the heart of Manhattan. After dancing for five hours straight to Australian tech-house DJ, FISHER, we were still willing to make that trek for a taste of MYKA’s Greek Frozen Yogurt, a recent social media favorite known for its authentic Greek yogurt base, at its location around the corner of Times Square.
20 minutes before the shop closed at midnight, it started pouring. Yet amidst the hazy night, a long line awaited outside MYKA, located right across Rockefeller. Dressed in micro shorts and tall boots with thin heels, my friends and I stood among the customers getting soaked. I scanned the line: young college students sporting NYU merch, a curious woman in a long trench coat whose glasses were fogging up in the rain, a father who just got off work as a lawyer and his teenage daughter…
At that moment, we all had one shared goal—to get frozen yogurt in the dead of night.
“Look at this line. It’s all from the social media propaganda,” the teenage daughter behind us told her dad, “I bet it isn’t even that good.”
It’s no surprise that social media, a trendsetter, was a major contributor to fro-yo’s recent spike in popularity, but what exactly is it about frozen yogurt that appeals to people?
In Cambridge, Massachusetts, at a small, brick-paved junction in Harvard Square, stands Berryline, another frozen yogurt spot that draws a line out the door every day. Dubbed as “the hottest Boston club to get into,” Berryline has become a hotspot for fro-yo enthusiasts.
13-year-old Lily and her friends all live around the area, and their Lululemon keychains dangled as they savored their fro-yo piled with colorful toppings.
“I think it’s just that there’s a lot of variety and a lot of different flavors,” Lily said when asked why she loves fro-yo. “There’s a lot of toppings that you can get and customize it.”
At Berryline, the shop markets its toppings as “fresh and homemade,” offering everything from fresh fruits, homemade mochi and cheesecake bites, to everyday classics like gummy bears and Oreos.
The freedom to customize their own fro-yo bowls has become a key factor in attracting consumers. Unlike ice cream, which consumers might choose in a single flavor, fro-yo offers a more personal experience, allowing customers to openly experiment with different flavors and toppings of their choice.
Campbell Engler, a Yogurt Beach Manager of four years, has observed how much people enjoy fro-yo’s customizability.
“Since we have 30-plus toppings and eight-plus flavors, people are always wanting to try new combinations as well.”
Yogurt Beach, located in Newton, Massachusetts, is a small, family-owned business. Known for its self-serve fro-yo setup that echoes the 2000s, the shop sees many customers in and out every day, some of whom drive for 40 minutes just to try its fro-yo.
“I definitely think people, especially high schoolers, high school girls, they post [online] about how much they love Yogurt Beach,” Engler noted. “They post about all the toppings, they post about all of that good stuff. I definitely think that helps a lot of our business too.”
Social media has helped drive the popularity of many fro-yo spots, including Berryline and Yogurt Beach, attracting customers and followers who visit the shops just after discovering them online.
But social media’s influence extends beyond enriching businesses. It has become a cultural bridge that connects people from all over the world to visit hidden gems that they wouldn’t have otherwise known about.
Karen, a study-abroad student in London from China, visited Berryline after seeing the shop on XiaoHongShu, a Chinese lifestyle social media platform. She was visiting Boston for a day-trip before heading to New York City for vacation.
“I just accidentally saw a post [of Berryline] on the Chinese social media [platform] called RedNote, [or] XiaoHongShu. So they’re quite popular,” Karen says.
Karen and her friend visited Berryline because, as she explains, London is sparse in good quality frozen yogurt. “We are currently living in London right now, but in London they don’t have that much great frozen yogurt, so we just want to try how different the frozen yogurt [is] in the world.”
By introducing travelers like Karen to local favorites across the globe, social media has done more than bringing customers to shops’ doors; it has also created opportunities for people to explore and create connections through shared interests across cultural boundaries.
However, frozen yogurt’s relationship with the media is nothing new. Decades before social media, fro-yo was already being marketed around a recurring cultural fixation: health.
In Charlestown, Massachusetts, a man by the name of H.P. Hood invented the earliest version of frozen yogurt in 1978, which he regarded as “Frogurt.” It wouldn’t be long before the frozen treat took off in the ‘80s.
The ‘80s were all about “health is wealth.” As Americans became more wary of the food production process and more laws were enacted to demonize saturated fats, refined sugars, and carbohydrates, concerns about food safety grew as food quality declined.
Amid this climate emerged the glamorous fitness craze that dominated the decade. Celebrities such as Jane Fonda wore colorful, neon spandex and promoted high-impact aerobics through at-home workout videos, serving as an ambassador for heart-disease prevention, an important health consideration at the time.
In a Vox article investigating the hype around frozen yogurt, award-winning journalist Rachel Kurzius examines the nutritional appeal in fro-yo’s popularity:
“In previous iterations, it was all about what Fro-yo didn’t have. For example, Froyo was low fat or fat-free. Fro-yo was low- calorie. Whereas this time around, the emphasis is all on what Froyo does have, right? So Froyo has a lot of protein. Froyo has probiotics and even prebiotics and all kinds of live cultures.”
In light of health concerns in the ‘80s, the first-wave of the fro-yo renaissance attracted health-conscious consumers eager to indulge without guilt, as companies marketed it as a lower-calorie alternative to traditional ice cream. Meanwhile, the most recent resurgence of fro-yo has stemmed from society’s newfound obsession with “proteinmaxxing” (a viral fitness trend focused on maximizing dietary protein intake, often with the goal of building muscle and reducing body fat).
Yet at the same time, the underlying motive remains the same—a pressure for thinness and wellness. It’s much easier to say that one is eating froyo because it has health benefits than it is to say that one is eating it because it’s lower in calories. It all comes down to what society considers socially acceptable.
Harvard students Zoe and Alice are frequent visitors to Berryline back in Cambridge. Zoe acknowledges how fro-yo’s nutritional propaganda influences her preferences.“It’s not like I’m ever gonna be like, ‘Oh, I’m not gonna have ice cream today,’” she says. “But if I’m choosing between the two and I want to be mindful of being healthier, then I might get a fro-yo.”
Fro-yo has come to acquire an implicit association with health, but while the appeal of fro-yo speaks to society’s expectations around food, Alice highlights another side of the experience: the simple pleasure of sharing a sweet treat with one another.
“The line [at Berryline] itself is also a good place for people to talk and chat,” Alice says, “And I think that getting a small bite or a snack and dessert specifically is a lot more accessible than sitting down for, like, a whole meal with someone.”
Many young people are drawn to fro-yo because “going to get froyo” creates a third space to either hang out with friends or meet new people. Just a 15-minute wait in a line like Berryline’s can spark spontaneous conversations between strangers, creating an opportunity for human connection.
With so much of social interactions happening through social media these days, these small every day outings to get fro-yo with familiar flavors, fun toppings, and grounding conversations, remind people of the simple joys in life
Between the long wait and cold shivers from the rain, I looked back to see how far the line had stretched out. It was now four minutes before MYKA’s Greek Frozen Yogurt closed at midnight in New York City, yet the line had grown even longer. I stepped forward, reaching the front of the line with my friends and I smiled, thinking about how each of us in line, all with a life on our own, had ended up here with one common goal—to get fro-yo.

